CA-GREET

The CA-GREET model is a California-specific version of Argonne National Laboratory’s GREET life cycle model which is used to calculate GHG emissions under the California Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS). Life Cycle Associates developed the original model for the California Air Resources Board (ARB) based on GREET version 1.8b.

CA_GREET

In early 2015, ARB developed two new CA-GREET models for first and next generation fuels, referred to as “Tier 1,” and “Tier 2” fuels, respectively.  The difference between first-generation and innovative/next-generation fuels is easily ascertained from the model:  fuels not included in the Tier 1 model are in the Tier 2 category.

  • CA-GREET 2.0 – Tier 1: For conventionally produced first-generation fuels (Corn-, sorghum-, and sugar-based ethanol,
    biodiesel, renewable diesel, CNG, LNG, CARBOB, and ULSD)
  • CA-GREET 2.0 – Tier 2:* For next-generation fuels (Cellulosic alcohols, hydrogen, drop-in fuels, etc.)

 

CA_GREET Tier1 and Tier2

 

Key differences between CA_GREET and the default GREET model

  • CA_GREET is configured with criteria pollutant emission factors that reflect California emission standards and emission policies.
  • CA_GREET has a regional lookup table with regional inputs that allows a user to select from eight regions in a pull-down menu, representing feedstock and fuel regions involved in the production of California fuels, and California-specific input parameters rather than U.S. average parameters.
  • CA_GREET includes new fuel pathways based on the existing GREET structure.  The model is configured for CNG and LNG from dairy digester gas and landfill gas, respectively.  The model is also configured for waste cooking oil and tallow pathways.  The model is not populated with all of the inputs for numerous sub-pathways such as corn and sugar cane ethanol.  Developing additional sub-pathway inputs still require user modifications.

Using CA-GREET

CA-GREET calculations are contained in a spreadsheet, which is publicly available and not user-protected. The user can download the spreadsheet, modify any of the inputs, or formulate and observe the effects on the results and intermediate calculations. The CA-GREET fuel sheets follow the same spreadsheet structure as the original GREET model.

The inventory data contained in the CA-GREET model is derived from many sources, including the set of California Energy Commission documents in support of AB1007. Additional GREET data is derived from Argonne National Laboratory publications, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Energy Information Administration (EIA), and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The CI varies for different natural gas pathways.

Fuel pathway calculations using CA-GREET

The California Air Resources Board has released fuel pathway documents for the LCFS that describe fuel pathway inputs, calculations, and results from the CA-GREET model in some detail, and are available on the ARB website. The fuel pathway documents (one per pathway) detail all of the assumptions and calculations for the fuel pathway. The results are disaggregated by pathway step. Fuel developers are expected to provide a comparable level of detail for Method 2B calculations under the LCFS.

We also develop custom overlays to the CA-GREET model that allow for the preparation of fuel pathway calculations for the California Low Carbon Fuel Standard. Having developed the model modifications, we can navigate through the model to extract calculation results of interest in any application. The  table below shows the disaggregated emissions for some of the farming emissions for a corn ethanol plant. Disaggregating the model results to this level of detail enables more effective reporting and error checking.

CA_GREET Disag

 

Follow the ongoing evolution of commentary regarding GREET and CA_GREET

The GREET model results depend on both the inputs and the modeling calculations.  The approach to co-products and distribution of energy inputs and emissions to different fuel types are important modeling parameters in the model.

Concerning the Electricity Mix in CA GREET, Life Cycle Associates submitted the following comment for CARB’s Board Hearing on February 19, 2015, which considers the re-adoption of a revised Low Carbon Fuel Standard:

> Electricity Mix in CA GREET

The approach for the calculation of emissions for petroleum refining has evolved in GREET and other LCA models. Some of the key factors affecting the emissions from petroleum products are discussed here:

> October 10, 2014: Update on GREET1_2014 and CA_GREET2.0

Note: The Tier 2 model appears to be a template and not fully active, we will keep you posted on new releases!